| 2025 |
Rocket |
86.600 |
13th |
| 2024 |
Creatures |
83.675 |
16th |
| 2023 |
Up Down and All Around |
83.625 |
15th |
| 2021 |
Bottle Tree |
- |
- |
| 2019 |
Neon Underground |
85.587 |
13th |
| 2018 |
Knock |
85.588 |
13th |
| 2017 |
Crossroads: We Are Here |
80.075 |
18th |
| 2016 |
Georgia |
76.675 |
21st |
| 2015 |
Out of the Ashes |
78.125 |
18th |
| 2014 |
Magnolia |
81.550 |
17th |
| 2013 |
Speakeasy |
86.400 |
11th |
| 2012 |
Sin City |
84.400 |
11th |
| 2011 |
ATL Confidential: A Tribute to Film Noir |
85.350 |
12th |
| 2010 |
Forging an Icon |
81.450 |
16th |
| 2009 |
Live... In Concert! |
80.450 |
17th |
| 2008 |
Per-if-4-ry |
83.175 |
15th |
| 2007 |
Genesis |
84.500 |
12th |
| 2006 |
Old, New, Borrowed, and Blue |
84.825 |
12th |
| 2005 |
The Spirit of Broadway |
86.075 |
12th |
| 2004 |
The Architecture of Life |
86.300 |
13th |
| 2003 |
TIME |
84.400 |
12th |
| 2002 |
Darkness Into Light |
85.450 |
10th |
| 2001 |
Ghost Train |
84.050 |
13th |
| 2000 |
Southern Harmonies... Music For the New South |
80.650 |
15th |
| 1999 |
Jump, Jive, Jazz and Wail |
76.900 |
16th |
| 1998 |
- |
83.100 |
14th |
| 1997 |
Southern Jazz: Spirit Style |
76.500 |
17th |
| 1996 |
By George... It's Gershwin |
68.000 |
23rd |
| 1995 |
All On a Southern Afternoon |
72.100 |
20th |
| 1993 |
A Soulful Celebration |
77.900 |
17th |
| 1992 |
Songs of the New South |
78.800 |
16th |
| 1991 |
- |
82.500 |
15th |
| 1990 |
- |
83.400 |
11th |
| 1989 |
- |
82.200 |
14th |
| 1988 |
Petrouchka |
89.300 |
9th |
| 1987 |
- |
87.600 |
10th |
| 1986 |
- |
94.100 |
6th |
| 1985 |
- |
91.000 |
7th |
| 1984 |
- |
93.100 |
6th |
| 1983 |
- |
83.600 |
7th |
| 1982 |
- |
81.650 |
12th |
| 1981 |
- |
83.850 |
9th |
| 1980 |
- |
89.800 |
4th |
| 1979 |
- |
89.900 |
4th |
| 1978 |
- |
86.500 |
6th |
| 1977 |
- |
76.350 |
23rd |